For years I was a Loreal Voluminous Carbon black mascara user, I never thought I would use another. A few months back I jumped on the Maybelline Falsies Mascara bandwagon and for a while it was okay but it was one of those "wet" products. One day I was out of mascara so I went into my local Dollar Store and found a $2 mascara that I have been using for the past 2 months. When I tell you this mascara doesn't smudge, it doesn't smudge. Lengthens my lashes, very black, intense color and the price is amazing. I have very oily lids and whenever I would use mascara on my lower lashes I would end up with raccoon eyes. This is my favorite at this time but honestly, I don't see myself looking for another.